Skip navigation

Butter vs margarine in baking

Pastry & Ingredients Guide

In any recipe from the family notebook or a modern pastry book, the choice of fat dictates the final result. The velvety texture, crispy puff pastry layers, or irresistible aroma that fills the kitchen all start from a single classic question: butter or margarine?

Fresh butter and vegetable fat for baking on the kitchen countertop

When you open the oven door and are greeted by the warm aroma of vanilla and browned dough, you know your dessert is a success. Behind every perfect cake lies a fascinating and very precise chemistry. Fat is not just any random ingredient on the shopping list, but the structure that binds the dough, the main carrier of flavours, and the element that decides whether a bite will be fluffy, crisp, or melt-in-the-mouth.

For decades, the dilemma between butter and margarine has divided home cooks and professional pastry chefs into two passionate camps. On the one hand, lovers of authentic taste choose pure dairy butter without hesitation, prized for its unmistakable fresh milk flavour. On the other hand, those preparing vegan desserts or looking for baked goods that stay soft for days turn with confidence to quality vegetable margarine.

So you know exactly what to put in the mixer bowl the next time you bake an aromatic loaf cake, a crisp tart, or a tray of tender crescent cookies, we have analysed all the technical, taste, and practical aspects. Read on to discover how each fat works and how to achieve the best desserts right at home.

Butter: noble taste, golden caramelization, and the flavor of pure milk

Fresh cow's milk butter with a creamy texture on a porcelain plate

Butter remains the quintessential noble ingredient in European pastry. Obtained exclusively by churning fresh cream from cow's milk, standard butter contains a minimum of 80% or 82% pure fat, around 16% water, and between 1% and 2% milk solids, composed of noble proteins and lactose.

This seemingly simple composition hides a culinary miracle. During baking at temperatures above 130 degrees Celsius, the milk proteins and lactose undergo the Maillard reaction, producing irresistible aromatic compounds with notes of toasted hazelnuts, toffees, and fresh cream. No neutral vegetable fat can replicate this aromatic richness.

Another decisive element is the melting point: between 32 and 35 degrees Celsius. Because this value is below the human body temperature of 36.5 degrees Celsius, cakes made with butter melt instantly on the tongue, offering a silky and pleasant sensation without any residual greasy film.

The pastry chef's secret: When you cream soft butter with fine sugar, the sugar crystals cut tiny air pockets into the fat. This process, called creaming, creates the fluffy base for loaf cakes and sponge cakes. You can find exceptional options with 82% fat directly in the fresh butter section on Sezamo.

Baking margarine: prolonged softness, stability, and plant-based options

Modern baking margarine is produced from carefully selected vegetable oils through a contemporary interesterification process. This modern technological process eliminates the formation of harmful trans fats, offering a safe product with extremely stable technical parameters.

The main strength of baking margarine is its predictable behavior and resistance to temperature variations. It has a much broader plasticity range than butter, which means it remains easy to incorporate even in a warm summer kitchen, without separating into liquid oil as quickly as butter.

Furthermore, thanks to plant molecular bonds and added emulsifiers, doughs made with margarine retain moisture excellently. Cakes and pastries remain soft and tender even 4 or 5 days after baking, without drying out or crumbling stiffly when stored in the pantry.

Plant-based baking fat prepared in a bowl for fasting doughs
Ideal for fasting

Being 100% plant-based, it is the primary choice for vegan desserts and traditional pastries during fasting periods.

Extended shelf life

Doughs do not turn hard when cold and retain their soft texture considerably longer than those made with animal fat.

Economical and practical

For large batches of homemade baked goods or everyday trays of biscuits, it offers an excellent cost-to-volume ratio.

The science on the baking sheet: melting point, aeration, and the steam that tenderizes dough

Rolling out shortcrust pastry with a rolling pin on a floured work surface

In baking, fat plays three fundamental roles: it shortens gluten strands (the classic shortening or tenderizing effect), creates stable emulsions with liquids, and releases water as steam during baking.

The difference in behavior in the oven starts with the melting point. Butter melts at 32-35 degrees Celsius, while margarine melts at 38-42 degrees Celsius. In the first 5 minutes in the oven, butter dough becomes fluid faster, allowing cookies to spread thinly on the tray and develop crispy, caramelized edges.

Margarine resists heat longer before melting completely. The dough structure has time to set around the air pockets before the fat liquefies, resulting in cookies that are more domed, softer, and more compact in shape.

Puff pastry physics
The power of steam in butter

Butter contains about 16% pure water distributed in fine droplets. When cold dough hits the oven heated to 200°C, this water instantly turns into powerful steam, forcing the dough layers to separate into dozens of crisp, airy flakes.

The chemistry of tenderizing
Protection against gluten

Fat coats the flour particles and prevents wheat proteins from forming a tough, elastic gluten network. For tender doughs that melt in your mouth, always pair high-quality fat with a fine, premium baking flour.